Tax Planning
Moving to Tennessee for the Taxes: What a Retiree Actually Saves
Everyone moving here has heard that Tennessee has no income tax. That part is true. Counting what it is actually worth means looking at what your old state was already doing, and at one year that matters more than the rate.
Short Answer
Tennessee genuinely does not tax income, and the Hall tax on interest and dividends was repealed for tax periods beginning in 2021 or later, so the state layer of your tax picture mostly disappears when you move here. What that is worth to you is a subtraction problem, and the published version of this question only ever shows one side of it: a surprising number of states already exempt retirement income, so somebody leaving one of those saves close to nothing on the line they asked about. The biggest recurring line is usually property tax, which is set locally and almost never mentioned in relocation coverage, and the counterweight is a high combined sales tax rate. The single largest number, though, is usually the year you move, because once you are a Tennessee resident the state tax on a Roth conversion, a large capital gain, or an option exercise is zero. Nobody should move to Johnson City for the tax code. Once you have decided to move, when you do it and in what order is worth real money.
I get some version of this question a few times a year now, and it almost always comes from somebody who does not live here yet.
"We are looking at Johnson City. Everybody says Tennessee has no income tax. What does that actually save us?"
I like the question. It is the right instinct and it is asking about real money. My honest answer is usually some flavor of "less than you are hoping on the part you asked about, and more than you are expecting on two parts you have not asked about yet," which is a lousy thing to say to somebody at a chamber breakfast, so I usually end up promising to write it out and then not writing it out. I am writing it out.
I should flag a couple of things before I start. I am writing this as general education rather than as advice for your household, because the numbers below swing enormously depending on where you are coming from and what your income actually looks like. And tax rules move around. I believe this is accurate as I write it, and I would still check the current year before you decide anything on it.
What Tennessee Does, And What Your Old State Was Already Doing
I will give you the good news first, because it is real and it is not complicated.
Tennessee does not tax income. Not wages, not pension payments, not 401(k) or IRA withdrawals, not Roth distributions, and not Social Security. There is no individual income tax on the Department of Revenue's list of the taxes it administers, and the two that used to reach a retiree, the Hall tax on interest and dividends and the inheritance tax, both sit in the archived column now (Tennessee Department of Revenue: taxes). The Hall tax was repealed for tax periods beginning January 1, 2021, or later, so nobody files it anymore (Tennessee Department of Revenue: Hall income tax). No state estate tax either. And no annual state tax on the value of your vehicles, which quietly surprises people coming from Virginia or North Carolina who are used to writing that check every single year and had stopped noticing it.
If you move here, the state layer of your tax picture mostly disappears. Good. Now let me tell you why that sentence, sitting by itself, is not enough to make a decision on.
I want to be careful about how I say this next part, because the people who ask me are not being naive. They are reading exactly what gets published about this, and what gets published is half of a subtraction problem.
Tennessee having no income tax tells you what you will pay here, and nothing whatsoever about what you were paying there. And a surprising number of states already go easy on retirees specifically, which is the piece that keeps getting left out.
Illinois has an income tax and, as I write this, does not apply it to retirement income, so somebody pulling from an IRA in Illinois may already be paying nothing in state tax on those withdrawals and would save nothing at all by moving here on that particular line. Pennsylvania does something similar past a certain age. Mississippi exempts retirement income. New York exempts government pensions and part of other retirement income. Georgia has a large exclusion once you are old enough to claim it. Several states have been widening these carve-outs, and most have stopped taxing Social Security.
I am not going to list all fifty, and I would not want you relying on my summary of your state anyway. Every one of those carve-outs has conditions inside it, and the legislatures keep moving them. Get the current answer for your own state from that state's revenue department, on the specific kind of income you actually live on.
If you are retiring out of a state that already exempted the income you actually live on, then the recurring income-tax saving from moving to Tennessee is somewhere between small and zero, and I would much rather you hear that from me now, while it is just a fact about your situation, than run into it later when you are already unpacked and it feels like something went wrong.
If you are coming from a state that taxes retirement income at four or five percent with no meaningful exclusion, that is a completely different conversation and the saving is substantial and ongoing. Both of those people call me. They have usually read the same relocation articles.
So the first thing I want to know is not what Tennessee does. I want to know what your current state was already doing to the specific dollars you live on.
The Line Almost Nobody Leads With Is Property Tax
The Year You Move Is Worth More Than The Rate
I care about this part more than any of the rest of it, and it is the reason I think a move like this deserves a planner's attention instead of a spreadsheet's.
A Conversion Costs No State Tax Once You Live Here
Once you are a Tennessee resident, your state income tax on a Roth conversion is zero. There is no bracket to manage at the state level, because there is no state level. So a conversion you have been putting off, partly because your old state was going to take a bite out of it, gets materially cheaper the moment you are genuinely domiciled here. Run it. A hundred and fifty thousand dollar conversion, in a state with a five percent income tax, costs you seventy-five hundred dollars of state tax that simply does not exist on this side of the line. One decision. One year. Worth more than the entire first year of recurring savings in the illustration below. And most people sitting in the window between their last paycheck and the year required distributions begin already have a stretch of unusually low income where conversions deserve a look for federal reasons that have nothing to do with geography (IRS: Roth IRAs), so if the move happens to land inside that stretch, I think that is about as favorable as the setup gets. Hard to say how often it lines up that neatly. When it does, it is worth noticing.
Anything Else Whose Timing You Control
I would run that same logic through anything else whose timing you control. Realizing a large capital gain. Exercising something. Taking money out of a nonqualified deferred compensation plan, though I would flag that one specifically, because federal law protects your pension and your qualified plan money from being taxed by a state you no longer live in, while the protection for nonqualified deferred comp is narrower and turns on how the payments are actually structured. If you have a deferred comp balance, have somebody read the plan document before you move. That is not a rule I can give you in an article.
The House You Are Leaving Does Not Move With You
One more that catches people, and it tends to catch them afterward, which is the worst time to find it. When you sell the old home, the state where that home physically sits generally still gets to tax the gain, whether or not you live there anymore. Real property is taxed where it sits. Becoming a Tennessee resident on Tuesday and closing on the northern house on Friday does not put that gain out of the old state's reach. For plenty of households this never comes up at all, because the federal exclusion on a primary residence covers the whole thing and the state usually follows along behind it. Own the home and live in it for at least two of the five years before the sale and you may qualify to exclude up to $250,000 of the gain, or up to $500,000 on a joint return (IRS Topic 701, sale of your home). Most people clear that with room. But if you have been in the same house for thirty years in a market that ran, the gain above the exclusion is taxable, and at that point your basis matters enormously. Every kitchen, every addition, every roof, every window replacement, if you kept the receipts, adds to basis and comes back off the gain. My guess is that most people reading this threw those away a decade ago. Go look anyway. I have watched that search change the number by more than a whole year of the savings this article is about.
Residency Is A Fact Pattern, And The State You Left Gets A Vote
Changing your domicile is not a form you file somewhere. It is a pattern of facts about where your life actually is, and some states look closely when a higher-income resident leaves. Where you spend your days, and how many of them. Where you vote and where you are licensed to drive. Where the cars are titled, where your doctors are, where your church is, where the things you would grab in a fire are kept. Any homestead or residency benefit you are still quietly claiming somewhere else is a particularly loud fact. None of that is difficult. It is a list. But the mistake I see over and over is somebody doing four of the eight things, deciding that probably counted, never circling back to the other four, and then hearing two years later that the state they left has a different opinion about where they were actually living. Do all of them, do them on purpose, and write down when. Also worth knowing: the year you move is a split year, so you will likely file a part-year return in the old state covering the income you earned while you still lived there. That is normal. It is also one more reason to think about which side of the move a large transaction lands on.
What I Would Actually Want To Look At
If you are considering this, the things I would want in front of me are pretty simple. They are usually enough to tell somebody whether the tax story here is a pleasant side benefit of a move they were going to make anyway, or whether it is worth real money and some deliberate sequencing.
- What your current state does to the specific income you live on, from that state's revenue department rather than from a relocation article
- What the property tax bill actually looks like on the house you are considering, from the county trustee rather than from a listing site
- Whether you have a conversion, a capital gain, an option exercise, or a deferred comp balance whose timing you control
- What year you would realistically establish residency, and which side of that line each of those transactions would land on
- The plan document behind any nonqualified deferred compensation, read before the move rather than after
- The basis receipts on the house you are selling: every kitchen, addition, roof, and window replacement you can document
- A first-year budget line for sales tax on the furniture, appliances, and vehicles a new house quietly requires
- Whether the Tennessee property tax relief or tax freeze programs apply to you, asked about once you are here rather than planned around in advance
Where Tennessee Takes Some Of It Back, And What Geography Does Not Decide
Now the counterweight, because I would rather write the honest version of this page than the flattering one.
The combined sales tax rate here is high. The general state rate is 7 percent on most tangible personal property and taxable services, local governments stack their own rate on top, and the local rate cannot exceed 2.75 percent, so the combined rate on most purchases lands somewhere under 9.75 percent depending on exactly where you happen to be standing when you buy the thing (Tennessee Department of Revenue: sales and use tax rates). Food gets a lower state rate, 4 percent, and the local piece still applies, so groceries here are not free of it the way they are in a number of other states.
I think for most retired households this is real money without being a plan-changer. Spend thirty-five thousand a year on taxable goods and services and you are looking at roughly thirty-three hundred dollars of sales tax. Coming out of a six percent state, call it eleven hundred dollars a year moving the wrong direction.
Where it actually stings is the first year, and I never see anybody warn people about this. You move into a new house and then you buy furniture, appliances, a mower, window treatments, curtains nobody told you cost that much, and possibly a vehicle, and forty thousand dollars of setup purchases quietly carries something like thirty-eight hundred dollars of sales tax along with it. That is one-time. It is not a reason to do anything differently. I just think it belongs in your first-year budget instead of arriving as a surprise.
I want to name what I am setting aside, because I do not want this reading as more complete than it is. Conversions interact with Medicare premium surcharges a couple of years down the road, they interact with how your kids eventually get taxed on what is left, and none of that is decided by geography. Tennessee makes the state layer free. It does not make the decision obvious.
And I will say the obvious thing out loud, because I think it matters more than any of the arithmetic above. Nobody should move to Johnson City for the tax code. People move here for the mountains, or to be closer to grandkids, or because a house here costs about what a down payment costs where they came from, or because they got tired of February. Taxes are a good reason to think carefully about when you move and in what order you do things once you decide. They are rarely the reason to go.
Follow-Up Questions
What do the numbers look like on a made-up couple?
Let me put numbers on a made-up couple, and I want to be clear that they are an illustration and not a recommendation for anyone. Their situation is not yours. Say they are leaving a Midwest state, pulling ninety thousand a year out of IRAs on top of Social Security, and the old house carried a nine thousand dollar property tax bill. If their old state taxed that IRA income at about five percent, they save something like forty-five hundred a year. If their old state exempted retirement income, they save nothing at all there. Property tax on a comparable house here might save them six thousand. Sales tax hands maybe eleven hundred of it back. So depending entirely on which state they left, the recurring answer is somewhere between roughly five thousand and roughly nine and a half thousand dollars a year. Both versions are worth having. And in both versions the largest single line is property tax, which is the line almost nobody writing about this ever mentions. That is the recurring picture. I have also come to think it is the smaller half of the story.
Does Tennessee tax my Social Security or my IRA withdrawals?
No. There is no individual income tax on the list of taxes Tennessee's Department of Revenue administers, and the Hall tax that used to reach interest and dividends was repealed for tax periods beginning in 2021 or later (Tennessee Department of Revenue: taxes). Wages, pension payments, 401(k) and IRA withdrawals, Roth distributions, Social Security: the state layer on all of it is zero. What that is worth to you is a different question, and it is the one the rest of this article is about.
Do I still owe my old state anything after I move?
Often yes, in the year you move and sometimes after. The year of the move is a split year, so you will likely file a part-year return in the old state covering the income you earned while you still lived there. And real property is taxed where it sits, so the gain on the house you are selling generally stays within reach of the state that house is in, whatever your driver's license says by then. Federal law protects your pension and qualified plan money from a state you no longer live in; the protection for nonqualified deferred compensation is narrower and turns on how the payments are structured, which is a plan-document question rather than an article question.
Does it matter what time of year I move?
It can matter more than the rate does, and this is the part I would actually plan around. Anything whose timing you control, a Roth conversion, a large capital gain, an option exercise, lands on one side of the residency line or the other. The same transaction can carry a state tax bill in April or carry none at all, depending on which state you were domiciled in when it happened. So the sequence I would want is: establish residency deliberately and on the record, then do the transaction. Not the other way around, and not both in the same confused week.
Sources
Related Talley Wealth Resources
If this question is on your mind, these pages are natural next reads:
Next step
See What Your Own Version Of These Numbers Looks Like
If you are somewhere in that decision and you would like to see what your own version of these numbers looks like, that is exactly what a no-pressure Explore Call is for. Short conversation, nothing to prepare, and if we are not the right fit for you I will tell you so directly.
For discussion purposes only. This is not individualized legal, tax, or investment advice. Any examples are hypothetical and for illustration only. State and local tax rules change, so please check the current year and talk through your own numbers with the right professional before acting.